Part 3 · Topic 27 of 37
FISH - Fault, Impact, Solution, Help
A four-step reflection tool for debriefing a fault with a learner - establish the fault, explore its impact, let them find the solution, then agree the help they want. The questions to ask at each step, and how it fits See it, Say it, Sort it.
Key facts
- FISH stands for Fault, Impact, Solution and Help
- You ask the questions; the learner supplies the answers - FISH is a reflection tool, not a correction script
- Help comes last: agree what support the learner wants before you offer any
FISH is a simple reflection tool for the moment something has gone wrong. It gives you four steps to work through with the learner - Fault, Impact, Solution, Help - so that a mistake becomes a piece of learning rather than a telling-off. It is the working detail behind See it, Say it, Sort it, and it pairs with the scenarios in adapting the lesson.
The whole tool rests on one rule: don't tell - ask. Every step below is a set of questions for the learner to answer. If you find yourself supplying the answers, you have stopped coaching.
F - Fault
Establish what actually happened, neutrally and specifically, before anyone tries to fix it.
- What went wrong?
- What happened?
- Why did it happen?
- Where did it happen?
Resist the urge to name the fault yourself. A learner who can describe their own error has already done half the learning; a learner who has been told what they did has done none of it. If they genuinely cannot see it, narrow the question rather than answering it - "what were you looking at as we came out of that bend?"
