Part 3 · Topic 36 of 37
What the examiner is looking for
The DVSA examiner guidance behind the SC1 form - what a 0, 1, 2 or 3 actually means, the three automatic fails, why scores have to be consistent with each other, and the evidence of competence and lack of competence the examiner watches for on each of the 17 competencies.
Key facts
- 0 = no evidence of competence, 1 = a few elements, 2 = competence in most elements, 3 = competence in all elements
- Three automatic fails: 7 or less in risk management, stopping the lesson because someone was put in immediate danger, and giving technically incorrect information that could create a safety-critical situation
- Scores must be consistent - you cannot score 0 for identifying goals and 3 for an appropriate lesson structure
Documents
The National Standard and SC1 form covers what is marked. This covers how - the guidance DVSA gives its own examiners about what to watch for and how to score it. It is published, it is the most useful preparation document there is, and most trainees never read it. (Content drawn from DVSA examiner guidance, Crown copyright, reproduced under the Open Government Licence - both source pages are linked above.)
What each score means
Every one of the 17 competencies is scored 0 to 3, and the guidance defines them plainly:
| Score | Definition | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | No evidence of competence | No meaningful attempt was made. You need considerable support in this area. |
| 1 | A few elements of competence demonstrated | You know something about it, but performance is not acceptable and a lot more work is needed. |
| 2 | Competence demonstrated in most elements | Performance is acceptable, with clear areas that could improve. |
| 3 | Competence demonstrated in all elements | No further work needed in this area. |
The useful takeaway is that 2 is a pass-level mark, not a good one. A grade B is a car full of 2s. Grade A comes from turning 2s into 3s, and the difference is almost always about whether the pupil did the thinking.
